Monday, 11 June 2012

Favourite Paintings - Van Gogh's 'Crab on its Back'

Here's a painting that I really love, and try to see at the Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam whenever I'm there (it's not always on display).  It's Vincent van Gogh's Crab on its Back, painted the year before he died.

Vincent Van Gogh, Crab on its Back (Oil, 1889)

It's not a very big painting....

..and is of a very ordinary subject.  Van Gogh had a real burning need to paint, and did so pretty much every day.  You get the feeling that perhaps the weather was too bad outside to go out to paint on this particular day, so he grabbed the first thing that came to hand indoors and set to work on it.  Perhaps it was his dinner...

Have a look at the picture.  How would you choose to paint a crab?  

He's put it on its back, off-centre, tipped up towards the light, at an awkward uneasy angle that gives a feeling of struggle.  He's deliberately put something under the shell at the back to tip it up so that it looks like that.  The sense of movement and struggle is further echoed by the surrounding brushstrokes. 

It has a background of sea green, which acts as a complimentary to the orangey red of the legs.  The brushstrokes are bold and obvious in the background, painted fast and with urgency using a flat brush about 3/4" wide.  The crab itself has been painted with a narrower round brush, and in the area of the ends of the legs it almost looks like a watercolour brush has been used, the lines are so fine.

So there are lots of contrasts going on - the large crab claws at the front have a real volume and strength to them, while the small legs at the back look spindly and frail.  The painting has contrasts of complimentary colours playing off each other, areas of luscious thick paint then passages of great delicacy, and the taking of a humble, everyday object that has been elevated to something monumental, made the entire subject of a painting - just like the  peasants that Van Gogh drew so often in his early years.

But there's more than that.  It's a crab on its back.  Something with a hard shell that's revealing its soft, vulnerable underside.  He's using the crab to say something about himself and his own feelings and siutation.

Have a look at this.

Eugene Delacroix, Christ on the Sea of Galilee (Oil, 1853)

This is Delacroix's painting Christ on the Sea of Galilee, painted the year that Van Gogh was born.  Van Gogh knew and admired this painting, mentioning it in his letters.  He admired Delacroix' "symbolic language through colour alone".  

Delacroix was an artist who knew a thing or two about colour, and wasn't afraid to use complimentaries as major themes in his work.  Have a look at that viridian green colour of the turbulent water and the orangey-red colour of the boat and the figures with their flailing arms.  Remind you of anything?

Delacroix's painting is about the vulnarability of a small shell of a boat on dangerous waters as Christ, the fisher of men,  sows the seeds of faith.  The image of a sower and reaper was very important to Van Gogh, who had of course initially been a preacher himself.

So the crab painting works on different levels of meaning - it's something low, common and ordinary, just a picture of a humble crab; but it's also something extraordinary, with a spiritual element to it.  It's vulnerable and fragile, but also enduring - something which will smell and decay tomorrow, but yet remains enduring and potent as a painting well over a century later.

It's a very, very beautiful painting, so if you ever get the chance to see it, please do.

(You can even order wools from a website that dyes them to match the colours of this particular painting - really! - which is very interesting, because Van Gogh used to have a box of wools, and used to spend time winding the different coloured strands together to see how they combined and the colours interacted with each other.

These are the wools to match Crab on its Back from website The Spun Monkey. I'm not sure what you're meant to do with them once you get them - knit your own masterpiece maybe!)


  1. nice posting.. thanks for sharing.

    1. Thank you Mr/Ms Anonymous - glad to know it's appreciated, and thanks for commenting.

  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  3. Thank you for your description of the painting!

  4. Your text is so true and to the point (or I'd rather say to the heart). I saw similar picture "Two crabs" in the recent exhibition at National Gallery "Depicting colour" and got haunted by it. I am a big fan of Van Gogh and I enjoy reading about what other see in his pictures. Thank you for the comparison as well. Appreciate your comments!

    1. Many thanks indeed, Nelli.

      I'm very jealous that you managed to see the "Depicting Colour" exhibition at the National. I was dying to see it, but unfortunately didn't manage to get down to London! I'd be very interested to hear your comments on that exhibition.

  5. I saw this painting at the Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam and was surprised to see that someone else considers it a favorite.
    I literally stopped in my tacks and stared in awe as I turned the corner. I had never seen a photo or copy of it so had no Idea it existed.
    Your description says how the strokes were done to convey movement. They worked. To me I saw the crab with its legs struggling to right itself.
    What amazed me was how thick the paint was applied but was still tapered to points on the body of the animal.
    Just an awesome work.

  6. Thank you very much for taking the time to comment! It is such a wonderful painting.

    You might be interested to know that Van Gogh made another painting of the same crab, this time showing it in two different positions on the same canvas. It is in the National Gallery in London.

    It is interesting for two reasons: one, that Van Gogh was apparently inspired to paint a crab after seeing a recently published woodcut of a crab by Hokusai (Van Gogh being greatly influenced in his work by Japanese woodcuts), and secondly that he is painting two aspects of the same object. This is what Picasso started doing in 1906 when he was beginning the path to cubism, and painted work where there are different views of the same figure on the same canvas.

    This culminated in the ground-breaking work Les Demoiselles d'Avignon of 1907, where Picasso is combining multiple viewpoints into each figure. However, Van Gogh is experimenting with the beginning of this around 18 years earlier.

  7. Good blog... keep-up the good work.... May I share an Interview with Vincent van Gogh(imaginary) in

  8. Just a question, is this information of your opinion, or is it facts? Also Thank-you this helped a lot.

  9. , cúp pha lê giá rẻ, cúp pha lê cao cấp, mẫu cúp pha lê, đặt làm cúp pha lê, giá cúp pha lê, quà lưu niệm, quà tặng pha lê,

  10. Xưởng sản xuất Cúp golf giá rẻ, biểu trưng giải golf giá rẻ với nhiều mẫu mã đẹp, tư vấn thiết kế miễn phí theo yêu cầu của quý khách hàng. Bạn muốn giải thưởng trong cuộc thi golf của bạn là những chiếc cúp golf pha lê toát lên vẻ sang trọng và độc đáo? Hãy đến với Quà tặng pha lê Bình Minh để được tư vấn và lựa chọn.